The Time Has Come for Muslims to Realize That Democracy Is Not Their Path
(Translated)
News:
On October 18, 2025, during the launch of the Regional Head Election Participation Index in Indonesia, Bakhtiar Baharuddin, Director General of Politics and Public Government at the Ministry of Interior, stated that many people flocked to polling stations during the regional head elections throughout Indonesia to vote because of the allure of political money. Bakhtiar said on Saturday, October 18, 2025: "More than 70%, some even raised the percentage to 80%. So, political money is extraordinary. People go to polling stations not out of political awareness, but out of political money." He explained that the reason for this is that the majority of Indonesians are poor, and therefore, it is easy to exploit them through political money. Bakhtiar added: "Why is this happening? It turns out that our poverty rate, according to the World Bank, is 194.7 million out of 285 million Indonesians."
Comment:
1. These findings support the long-held suspicions that money politics is a constant feature of general elections. Most people do not vote for capable leaders, but for money. Therefore, it is natural for leaders chosen in this way to act arbitrarily towards their constituents. Furthermore, it is not surprising that corruption is widespread among officials, because assuming leadership requires a large amount of money. According to the 2024 Corruption Perceptions Index, Indonesia scored 37 (most corrupt) out of 100 (most honest). Compared to a student's grade in school, 37 is a failing grade. This indicates that society is sick. Ibn al-Qayyim al-Jawziyya, may God have mercy on him, mentioned in his book Miftah Dar al-Sa'adah (Volume II, pages 177-178): "And contemplate His wisdom, may He be exalted, in making the servants', emirs', and rulers' kings of the same kind as their deeds, but rather as if their deeds appeared in the images of their rulers and kings. If they are upright, their kings are upright, and if they are just, they are just towards them, and if they are unjust, their kings and rulers are unjust, and if deceit and deception appear among them, so are their rulers, and if they withhold God's rights from them and are stingy with them, their kings and rulers withhold from them what is due to them and bestow it upon them."
2. This official statement from the Ministry of Interior proves that the slogan of democracy "from the people, by the people, and for the people" is just an empty slogan. The truth is that democracy is "from the oligarchy, by the oligarchy, and for the oligarchy"; because in order to reach power, money is necessary, and the oligarchs are the ones who own the money. Therefore, the oligarchs finance them. Once they come to power, they enact rules and regulations that are in the interest of those who finance them during the elections. The oligarchs control wealth and the economy based on these rules and regulations for their own benefit. Furthermore, in democracy, the people's vote is not the true determinant of victory, but the institution that counts the votes. The Election Commission, which is the body that counts the people's votes in the elections, is not immune to corruption. In January 2025, the "Corruption Watch Indonesia" organization issued a report entitled "Budget Waste in Corruption: Problems in the General Election Commission and the Election Supervisory Body." The results indicate that between 2019 and 2023, at least 37 corruption cases were recorded relating to the General Election Commission and the Election Supervisory Body, with a total of 90 suspects. These cases included 21 corruption cases involving 44 individuals from within the General Election Commission, and 16 corruption cases involving 46 individuals from within the General Election Commission, at the provincial, district and city levels. Corruption within the General Election Commission and the Election Supervisory Body between 2019 and 2023 resulted in total state losses of 125.6 billion rupiah, and bribes of 2.1 billion rupiah. This is the essence of democracy.
3. Many people are deceived by democracy, especially with regard to majority voting. In fact, we find in the Qur'an many verses that show that most people are ungrateful for blessings ﴿BUT MOST OF THE PEOPLE DO NOT GIVE THANKS﴾, ignorant ﴿BUT MOST OF THE PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW﴾, and have no faith ﴿BUT MOST OF THE PEOPLE DO NOT BELIEVE﴾. Therefore, the time has come for Muslims to realize that democracy is not their path, but rather a system of disbelief that it is forbidden for them to resort to for judgment.
Written for the Media Office of Hizb ut Tahrir Central
Muhammad Rahmat Kurnia - Indonesia